REQUIRED JOINT RSTA CAPABILITIES
1. Overview. This chapter focuses on the broad capabilities that RSTA
assets must possess. No single system can stand alone to meet all the
JFC's information needs; therefore, the types of data that may be needed
will be addressed along with general characteristics of RSTA platforms
and capabilities.
2. Types of Information
(2) Imagery intelligence (IMINT).
Although not an intelligence discipline, meteorologic and
oceanographic information is required by the JFC to plan and conduct
combat operations. RSTA assets can provide timely data to
meteorological and oceanographic support forces that process the data
into information for JFC use.
Commanders also require mapping, charting, and geodesy (MC&G)
support to conduct military operations. MC&G support is provided
through the Defense Mapping Agency (DMA). Commanders identify
prioritized MC&G product and component requirements to DMA for
validation in accordance with CJCS MOP 31. DMA then requests RSTA
support to update the areas of interest. DMA normally requests
national-level RSTA support directly to national agencies.
Counterintelligence is a discipline separate and distinct from
foreign intelligence. Through the implementation of the four
functions of CI, operations, investigations, collection, and analysis
and production, CI can support the commander's RSTA capabilities.
Joint Pub 2-03, "Joint Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures for
Counterintelligence Support," provides commanders information on the
capabilities and responsibilities for CI support to the JFC and
component commanders.
(2) Limited specific collection capability with a broad range of
data.
(3) Near-real-time (NRT) collection systems that cover limited
geographical areas.
(4) Limited response systems that cover large geographical
areas.
Aerial systems are the primary source of RSTA assets for the JFC.
All the Services possess and operate these systems, which have
varying, but complimentary, capabilities, limitations, and operating
characteristics.
Future systems may include laser designators to
highlight targets for attacking weapon systems. The range and
endurance of UAVs vary considerably depending on the situations
for which they are designed to be employed. Close-range UAVs
(CR-UAV) have an approximate range of 50 km and provide the
capability for 24-hour coverage. Short-range UAVs (SR-UAV) have
an approximate range of 150 km beyond the forward line of own
troops (FLOT) and an endurance of approximately 8 to 12 hours.
Medium-range UAVs (MR-UAV) will serve as a tactical
reconnaissance platforms which will have a range on the order of
650 km, but will have an on station endurance of only two hours.
Presently, only one UAV system is fielded, the Pioneer system.
During Operation DESERT STORM, UAVs were successfully employed by
the Army, Navy, and Marine Corps to provide NRT day/night RSTA,
BDA, and battlefield management. The primary limitation of these
systems is their lack of flexibility. Generally, because of
their payload limitations, they can carry only one sensor and
must be either preprogrammed or controlled by personnel within
line of sight. The smaller, short-range unmanned systems,
although cheaper than manned systems, are limited in range and
payload. As their payload and loiter time increase, their cost
increases significantly. They are also susceptible to adverse
weather conditions. For a more detailed discussion of UAVs, see
Joint Pub 3-55.1, "Joint Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures for
Unmanned Aerial Vehicles."
(2) Manned aerial systems are also available to support RSTA
operations and offer the JFC several important capabilities.
They generally are among the most mobile and responsive RSTA
assets available, capable of carrying out critical missions and
gathering vital information in near-real-time. Manned systems
can often respond to changing conditions and may be able to
modify missions while in progress. They can cover relatively
large areas and can carry a wide range and mix of sensors,
including IMINT, MASINT, and SIGINT sensors.
Many RSTA systems
have common data link capabilities that can provide large volumes
of data. Other RSTA systems have voice-only or no NRT
dissemination capability. Without a NRT dissemination
capability, a RSTA system's critical information loses its
timeliness and, therefore, its usefulness to the consumer. Users
must understand RSTA assets must collect and
process their data prior to disseminating it. This processing
includes developing target data to a point where there is
confidence that the information is correct and required accuracy
is achieved. It is this processed data that is sent via the
dissemination medium.
The primary disadvantage of manned systems
is that they put friendly personnel at risk during military
operations where damage to RSTA assets has historically been
high. In addition, standoff requirements limit depth of sensor
capability before and during hostilities. Also, adverse weather
conditions degrade many of the sensor systems, especially optical
sensors.
Surface platforms also vary greatly in size and complexity, with
great differences between land-based and sea-based assets.
(1) Land-based RSTA assets provide a diverse mix of capabilities
that can range from a small force conducting a reconnaissance
patrol, to dedicated SIGINT and electronic warfare units, to
highly technical target acquisition radars. Such assets can be
employed to support operations across the operational continuum
and can obtain extremely diverse types of information. For
example, a reconnaissance patrol can determine the extent and
location of obstacles and defensive positions while also
performing counterreconnaissance operations to deceive and deny
friendly force disposition to the enemy.
As with aerial
platforms, there are advantages and disadvantages to land-based
RSTA systems. The primary advantage is that they are generally
organic to the tactical commander, allowing direct access to the
required information. However, their range is usually limited by
physical constraints or the military situation and the risk
factor of personnel assigned will need to be taken into account.
(2) Sea-based surface platforms have varying degrees of RSTA
capability, including organic manned and unmanned aerial
platforms. Part of this capability is required for defense of
maritime forces, such as sonar and underwater acoustic
surveillance of enemy submarines and surface ships and various
radar for air and surface targets. Other capabilities, such as
SIGINT-gathering assets, can support a broad range of military
activities ranging from monitoring arms control treaty compliance
to establishing enemy orders of battle and preparation of combat
strike plans.
Deployment aboard ships also provides sea-based
RSTA assets with several advantages. Ships have greater power
and load-carrying capabilities than do some other RSTA platforms,
enabling them to carry heavier and bulkier equipment that may
have greater information gathering and processing capabilities.
Ships also possess the advantages of mobility and sustainability,
enabling them to position and reposition RSTA assets. Access is
relatively unrestricted because maritime areas of interest to
RSTA are often close to international waters. Many classes of
ships have organic air assets that can extend shipboard sensor
horizons and provide valuable on-site reconnaissance. These
qualities at times provide advantages over other RSTA assets.
(3) Special operations forces (SOF) are valuable assets and
should be considered for employment in joint RSTA operations.
Special reconnaissance (SR) operations can be conducted when
there is a need to obtain or verify information about enemy
capabilities, intentions, and activities, or to gather data about
meteorological, hydrographic, or geographic characteristics of an
area not available using technical sensors. SR operations
complement national and theater RSTA assets across the
operational continuum to obtain specific, time-sensitive
information of strategic and operational significance. SOF offer
the availability of technically knowledgeable observers to verify
critical information about targets or target complexes. These
observers will use their human judgment to defeat enemy deception
attempts and transmit a more complete picture of what is
happening on the target.
Space systems have become an integral part of the national
military forces providing support across the
operational continuum and at all levels of war. Space systems provide
information allowing commanders to assess the situation, develop
concepts of operations, and disseminate changes to their forces
quickly. During Operations DESERT SHIELD and DESERT STORM, space
systems provided a myriad of support functions. These include
communications, navigation, surveillance, and environmental monitoring
support functions. However, commanders must be aware of the
advantages and limitations of these systems.
The prime advantage of
these systems as it pertains to RSTA is their ability to provide
worldwide, quick-reaction coverage of areas of interest, especially
those remote or hostile areas where little or no data can be obtained
from conventional sources. Other advantages these RSTA system possess
are their survivability and relative immunity to enemy action, the
ability to place satellites into orbits that maximize their
effectiveness, their mission longevity, and their ability to maneuver.
Their limitations, especially to surveillance systems, include
atmospheric and weather disturbances that effect most imagery systems.
In addition, space systems schedules are predictable and are therefore
vulnerable to deception practices and signature control activities
such as emission control, camouflage, etc. The kinds of support
provided by space systems are divided into military and nonmilitary
space systems.
Space surveillance systems' unique advantage of global coverage allows
commanders to observe areas of operations or other areas of
interest over great distances and where other RSTA systems cannot
be employed. Access to space surveillance information helps
commanders determine where the enemy is, how strong he is, and
what his intentions are. Detection and warning sensors
provide early detection of ballistic missile attack and down-link
this data to ground stations, allowing commanders to take
appropriate action against the missiles. Environmental
monitoring systems are crucial in understanding and reacting to
weather and ocean conditions that may affect military operations.
The information acquired by these systems helps in the assessment
of the environmental impacts on both friendly and enemy forces
alike. Ignorance of environmental conditions can jeopardize the
success of a mission. Space surveillance systems provide joint
forces with terrain and threat information necessary to enhance
mission planning capabilities. Often, these systems can cue or
be cued by other RSTA systems to watch a specific area of
interest, enhancing accuracy and reaction times to the user.
(2) Nonmilitary space systems (including civil, commercial, and
allied space capabilities) may augment DOD space systems. These
capabilities are used when they are the only means available to
provide the type of requested support, when the requests outstrip
available military means, or if primary DOD capabilities are
lost.
These systems possess a variety of capabilities, many of
which complement rather than duplicate those of DOD-controlled
space systems. These include weather, communications, and
multispectral imagery satellites. Remote sensing imagery was
used extensively by US and allied forces during air campaign
against Iraq for attack planning, target coordinates, and mission
execution. Additionally, these products were used extensively by
ground forces for terrain analysis and map substitutes. The JFC
may be able to task these systems directly depending on how
share-use agreements are negotiated with the owners. The next
chapter will discuss these procedures.
Geolocation Accuracy. Geolocation accuracy is a crucial
requirement for target acquisition, especially with the employment of
precision-guided munitions. Reconnaissance and surveillance may not
require pinpoint accuracy, but target acquisition requires a sensor
suite
that ultimately produces a target location or aim point suitable for
attacking systems.
Survivability. The same principles that the JFC must examine with
timelines hold true for the survivability of RSTA capabilities.
Survivability must be assessed for the entire RSTA system--collection
platforms, sensors, communications and data links, ground stations,
processing facilities, personnel and operators, etc. Not all systems,
or nodes within a system, will have the same degree of survivability,
nor is it necessary. Such an effort would be far too costly. RSTA
systems should possess survivability of the aggregate functions, e.g.,
survivability of an ELINT collection or photographic reconnaissance
capability. Survivability must be commensurate with the threats to
which the RSTA assets will be exposed during the course of operations.
These assets must be as survivable as the operational systems and
forces they support. Not only are many RSTA assets vulnerable, they
are also scarce, and commanders must consider how they would
compensate for the loss of a RSTA capability should any specific asset
or group of assets be destroyed or otherwise become unavailable.
Besides careful mission planning, intelligent tasking, and effective
employment tactics, redundancy and overlap of capability are perhaps
the best ways of ensuring the survivability of specific RSTA
capabilities and functions.
Reliability. RSTA systems must be able to provide reliable
information despite enemy deception measures such as camouflage and
decoys. This may require the employment of other RSTA systems to
verify information acquired by the previous systems. Operation DESERT
STORM provided many examples of one RSTA system identifying a
potential target or target set and cueing another system
to verify the target. As an example, Joint Surveillance and Target
Attack Radar System (STARS) was able to use its wide area radar search
capability to identify potential SCUD missile sites and relay the
information to an orbiting F-15E, which then used its radar to search
the area and attack the target if verified as a SCUD site. The
development and evaluation of RSTA systems should be integrated with
the development and evaluation of potential enemy concealment and
deception capabilities.
Suitability. Suitability is an important consideration in
planning the employment of collective RSTA assets. Tasking must be
based on an asset's capability and on its suitability within the
context of the
overall plan. For example, several assets may be capable of
collecting against a single target, although one or more of these have
unique capabilities against a second target. Intelligence
requirements may necessitate tasking these RSTA assets against the
second target if other assets can maintain adequate coverage of the
first target. Suitability also applies to the format of the processed
intelligence. Both the information and format must be useful to the
user. Intelligence analysts must avoid disseminating technical data
that only other intelligence analysts would understand. A key
objective of training exercises should be to determine new
requirements for RSTA systems and countermeasures, as well as better
ways to employ these complementary capabilities.
Connectivity. Connectivity is a critical aspect of any RSTA
system. Interoperability, commonality, reliability, and robustness of
sensors, data links, supporting ADP, and C3I systems are crucial to
the responsiveness, survivability, and overall combat effectiveness of
an RSTA system. If the components of a RSTA system are dissimilar, or
if connectivity among sensors, supporting systems, and supported
systems and elements is too fragile to withstand the stress of combat,
commanders will be deprived of important intelligence information
essential to conducting combat operations. The RSTA network must be
able to transmit accurate and timely information to those who must
receive it when they need it. Connectivity depends on active
management of the information flow. Tailoring information to the
needs of the commander prevents critical intelligence from being
delayed or lost in irrelevant data. Information on vital enemy
targets acquired by RSTA assets becomes useless unless
disseminated in a timely fashion to the forces tasked to attack and
destroy the targets. Interoperability, commonality, and connectivity
improve and unify RSTA capabilities and enhance execution planning.
Interoperability and commonality also improve the overall capability
of RSTA through cross-cuing, information enhancement, and analytical
exchange to accurately portray the battlefield. The multidiscipline,
multisource approach reduces the possibilities of being deceived by
the enemy.
Different types of information are required to support various
types of military operations; for example, the needs of a fleet
commander differ from those of an armored brigade commander. It is
important to note that RSTA operations do not always collect
intelligence; rather, they collect data that becomes intelligence
after it is processed, evaluated, and integrated with other pieces of
information and data (fused). The following is a list of intelligence
source types through which RSTA operations gather data and
information. This list reflects the variety of information that may
be needed by or be available to the JFC.
3. Collection Capabilities and Limitations
(1) Human resources intelligence (HUMINT).
Although there are many forms of intelligence, not all of them are
of immediate use to commanders and their staffs in planning and
conducting operations. For example, FISINT can provide important
technical information on enemy systems supporting technical threat
assessments and US weapon system acquisition activities; however, it
usually has very limited utility in the near term for planning or
conducting military operations. Comprehensive intelligence support to
the JFC requires analysis and integration of multiple intelligence
collection products in order to resolve ambiguities and provide the
most accurate information. Sanitization may be necessary to protect
sensitive sources and methods for information requiring broad
dissemination. Timely support also requires that information be
properly formatted for processing, display, and dissemination in a
manner that makes efficient use of available communications resources
and is in a form useful to the users.
(a) Electro-optical-infrared (EO-IR).
(3) Measurement and signature intelligence (MASINT).
(b) Photographic intelligence (PHOTINT).
(c) Synthetic aperture radar (SAR).
(a) Acoustic intelligence (ACINT).
(4) Signals intelligence (SIGINT).
(b) Infrared intelligence (IRINT).
(c) Optical intelligence (OPTINT).
(d) Laser intelligence (LASINT).
(e) Nuclear intelligence (NUCINT).
(f) Unintentional radiation intelligence (RINT).
(g) Radar intelligence (RADINT).
(a) Communications intelligence (COMINT).
(5) Counterintelligence (CI)
(b) Electronic intelligence (ELINT).
(c) Foreign instrumentation signals intelligence
(FISINT).
RSTA forces and assets that may be used in support of the joint
force encompass a broad range of capabilities and limitations to
include:
4. Required Capabilities. Lessons learned from Operations DESERT
SHIELD and DESERT STORM demonstrated that the speed of modern warfare
dictates that commanders receive timely and accurate information to
support them in the decisionmaking process. Along with being timely and
accurate, RSTA forces must be survivable, reliable, suitable, and
interoperable (connectivity). To achieve these capabilities, they must
be exercised during peacetime with the goal of being able to operate
within the commander's operational planning cycle. RSTA forces require
the following:
(1) Comprehensive collection systems with a narrow range of
data.
These assets provide the JFC the capability to obtain the information
required to plan and conduct successful combat operations. The assets
discussed here include aerial systems (manned and unmanned),
subsurface systems, surface systems (ground and sea), space systems
(military and nonmilitary), and national systems.
(1) Systems such as unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) offer
significant advantages and limitations. The greatest advantage
of these systems is that they are relatively threat-insensitive
because they normally do not put friendly personnel at risk.
Furthermore, because of their relatively small radar
cross-section, they can be sent into high-threat areas with an
enhanced probability of undetected ingress and mission
accomplishment. They can provide a broad range of collection
capabilities, including SIGINT,
ELINT, SAR, electro-optical, infrared imagery, multispectral
imagery, and real-time television imagery. UAVs can also be used
as a line-of-sight communications relay for forces attacking at
low level.
Subsurface systems vary greatly in size, complexity, and
capability. These include sensors generally best suited for long-term
surveillance of a specific and limited geographic region. Seismic
detectors, for example, can indicate that enemy forces might be moving
in an area, making further reconnaissance of the area useful.
Submarines, on the other hand, are invaluable platforms for
clandestine reconnaissance operations within waters peripheral to
enemy territory.
(1) Military space systems provide and support warfighting
capabilities. Military space systems employ a variety of sensor
suites and provide a broad and increased range of capabilities.
Space support focuses first on deterrence, and if deterrence
fails, on aiding, protecting, and complementing joint combat
operations. This principle in no way ignores the important
support that space forces provide to hostilities other than war
and war. Space systems routinely support military activities
during peacetime. These include, but are not limited to, joint
training exercises, peacekeeping operations, indications and
warnings, disaster and humanitarian assistance, and
counterterrorism and counternarcotics operations.
National RSTA systems are controlled by the US Intelligence
Community and provide direct support to the National Command
Authorities (NCA). The information provided by these systems is used
by senior government leaders to make strategic political or military
decisions, and is also of great utility to combatant commanders.
Information from national systems is provided to the JFC via Service
component Tactical Exploitation of National Capabilities Program
(TENCAP) systems. Army corps, numbered Air Force, or numbered Navy
fleet, or Marine Air-Ground Task Force (MAGTF) receive raw data or
processed reports, dependent upon the specific TENCAP equipment
organic within the element. Dependent upon the specific intelligence
discipline, timelines can be good--within seconds of collection.
Other disciplines are inherently slow--hours to days from the request.
Accuracy is system dependent. Additionally, the security of these
systems and their sources may require sanitization of the information
before it can be made available to the user. National RSTA systems
provide invaluable intelligence, especially when local access by
conventional RSTA systems is denied by range limitation, lack of air
superiority, or political reasons. The JFC must develop specific
requirements well in advance so the responses will be usable and
timely. These systems should be considered when the JFC's organic
RSTA assets cannot satisfy the intelligence requirements or to verify
information using another collection source. The JFC has the ability
to request specific support from these systems and should exercise the
process during peacetime exercises.
Timeliness. Joint RSTA assets must be sufficiently responsive to
meet the needs of the JFC at any point along the operational continuum
and in any scenario. The commander should have RSTA assets available
to provide information when and where needed. The responsiveness of
the RSTA assets available to any commander must be looked at in
aggregate and is driven by the missions that must be accomplished.
The JFC must examine the range of required missions and ensure that
appropriate and sufficient RSTA assets are obtained and positioned to
meet C2 needs.
12-26-1996; 11:36:13